Which one would you hang on your wall? | #3

Before I get into my next few thoughts, I’m sharing another link to one of my shots ("Landscape in the Mist"). The resolution is high enough for a large-format print, up to A1 size.
By the way, six people downloaded the last photo I shared. If any of you actually end up framing it and putting it on your wall, please let me know—I’d love to see it.

https://webshare.cz/#/file/8lkLgDXglz/dsc-0001-zip

Now, back to the main topic: photos for social media versus photos for sale and for the wall.

Whenever I discuss this, one question constantly comes up: should the photos be kept "clean," or should they be styled as a poster, a print, or something similar? And as usual, the answers have been pretty split.

When it comes to wall art, what feels right to you ‒ the raw, untouched photograph, or a fully realized poster design?

Those who prefer "clean" photos argue that they're more versatile and don't distract the viewer with extra design elements. I get that ‒ it’s the go-to choice for purists or collectors (whether they're into nature or vintage cars, like in these examples) who want the photo to stand on its own. In this case, the customer has full control over the frame, the matting, and even the crop.

On the other hand, turning a photo into a poster sends a different message: the customer isn't just buying a "snapshot," they're buying a finished piece of art. Let’s be honest ‒ most people aren't interior designers. Many would rather choose a complete graphic work that gives a room that modern, editorial feel. A poster doesn't just say, "here's a photo." It says, "here is an aesthetic perspective." The typography adds context and a certain authority. It ends up looking like a poster for a movie you'd actually want to live in.

To be clear, this isn't a competition where one side has to win and the other lose. In my view, each format has its own purpose and its own place. A standalone photo might belong in a study (or a workshop), while a poster might feel more at home in the living room. At the end of the day, it all comes down to the individual's taste.

You can find both versions in my shop at https://www.etsy.com/shop/SilverPixelLab. Over time, I guess the market will show me which direction people find more interesting.

What do you think?

Same as last time: feel free to rate them, criticize them, or even tell me they’re terrible. I’ll be releasing one of these in full resolution, ready to print.